So today I was in a salty mood. I knew someone was going to set me off. And they did. Surprisingly, it was someone from the Left side of the political sectrum. I hadn't seen that coming.
Granted, had I not been in such a bad mood, I'd probably have let the whole thing go. It was nothing really. A video by a nurse decrying the practice of male circumcision. And I did what I usually do: I made a joke. I said maybe we should ban haircuts too, until kids are able to give informed verbal consent.
And we were off to the races. I was called uninformed, was told I was making light of a serious issue, was told I was granting tacit consent to unauthorized "amputation" (yes, they went there), and was dared to watch a circumcision video without becoming squeamish. (FYI, I watched the video AND a slide show. All wihile snacking.)
I made the mistake of engaging in an argument, my main points of which were:
1. Male circumcision, unlike female circumcision, does not endeavor to deny anyone the pleasure of sensation, to control sexual behavior in adulthood, or to bond anyone into a servile relationship.
2. No, my parents were not butchers for having had me circumcised.
3. Perhaps we're all taking this stuff WAY TOO FUCKING SERIOUSLY.
Finally, exasperated and annoyed, I posted to my FB status that "intactivists" should just unfriend me now and save me the trouble of unfriending them individually later.
Another minor shitstorm followed, the salient point of which was this...
Male circumcision, like childhood immunization, is a personal choice that parents make for their kids. If you don't believe in it, don't do it. I don't care. But please do not clutter my page with videos telling me what a horrible person I am for tolerating the practice.
If you are an "intactivist" and are still reading, I promise I will not try to persuafe you to become an atheist, to smoke, to listen to blues music, or to do any of the other things I enjoy. Nor will I insist that you immunize your kids, breast- or bottle-feed them, or allow/deny violent films. Those are YOUR PERSONAL parenting choices.
* * *
But all this has made me nearly as dissatisfied with the Left as I am with the Right. From the Right, I get:
• You're a horrible person because you don't believe in Jesus
• You're a horrible person because you support gay marriage
• You're a horrible person because you support a woman's right to choose
etc. etc. etc.
And from the Left I get:
• You're a horrible parent if you favor male circumcision
• You're a horrible preson if you smoke
* You're a horrible person if you're not Green
etc. etc. etc.
My position is simple:
• I will not interfere with your belief in Jesus. Just don't try to make ME believe in Jesus (or Allah or Buddha or Vishnu, or anyone else).
• I don't keep score of who's gay or straight or bi or trans. The basic rights and respect enjoyed by one should be enjoyed by ALL. I promise not to try to "convert" anyone who is gay to being straight or vice versa. Ever.
• It's none of my business if you choose to terminate your pregnancy, see your pregnancy thru to term, opt for adoption, or raise your child. That's NOT my call to make. It is a personal choice.
• I don't give a chimp's pajamas if you circumcise your male children or not. Just don't try to convince me I'm a butcher if I opt for circumcision.
• I don't care if you smoke or don't. I won't light up in your elevators if you stop telling me not to light up outdoors.
• I won't mock you for having an organic garden or for having 20 solar panels on your house. Just leave my 72 Ford the hell alone.
Sometimes it seems as if the Right wants to make the world into a place where everyone is white, Christian, and straight... and as if the Left wants to make the world into a Disneyland where everyone is totally safe but nobody has a very good time. Both options suck.
I know we can do better.